What Is the Wisconsin Butter Burger?

Published by Drafted with AI; every statement checked against its source on November 19, 2026
A butter burger on a diner table with melted butter shining on the bun.
AI illustration: A simple burger scene that reflects a rich regional food tradition.

The butter burger is a Wisconsin food tradition: a hamburger shaped by butter, local diner history and the way each restaurant uses it. In Milwaukee, Solly's Grille traces its original Butter Burger to Kenneth "Solly" Salmon's 1936 coffee shop. Green Bay's Kroll's West is known for charcoal grilled Butter Burgers, while Culver's brought the ButterBurger name out of Sauk City in 1984 with a buttered, toasted bun. This statewide story fits naturally into Wisconsin's wider food culture.

Key facts

  • Solly's Grille began as Solly's Coffee Shop in 1936 and still calls itself the original Butter Burger.
  • Solly's says it uses 100 percent sirloin, Wisconsin farm fresh cheeses and creamy Wisconsin butter.
  • Kroll's in Green Bay began serving its local hamburger in 1936 and is known for charcoal grilled Butter Burgers.
  • Culver's opened its first Frozen Custard and ButterBurger restaurant in Sauk City on July 18, 1984.
  • Culver's ButterBurger comes from Ruth Culver's buttered, toasted top bun.

Own a house in Wisconsin you are thinking of selling? See how our cash offer works.

What a butter burger means in Wisconsin

A Wisconsin butter burger is a hamburger whose identity comes from butter, but the butter does not show up in only one way. At Solly's, the restaurant points to 100 percent sirloin, Wisconsin farm fresh cheeses and creamy Wisconsin butter. At Culver's, the defining move is a buttered top bun that is lightly grilled until toasted. Kroll's West in Green Bay ties its Butter Burgers to a charcoal grill, a method the restaurant connects with a signature smoky flavor. That range is why the dish feels statewide rather than standardized.

A close view of a butter burger with butter melting into the bun beside fries.
AI illustration: This kind of burger is defined by how butter becomes part of the bun and the meat.

Milwaukee chapter: Solly's Grille

Solly's began in 1936 as Solly's Coffee Shop, opened by Kenneth "Solly" Salmon, and it still presents itself as the original Wisconsin Butter Burger. The restaurant's details make the dish feel like diner history you can still understand at the counter. Solly's says it uses 100 percent sirloin, Wisconsin farm fresh cheeses and creamy Wisconsin butter. Wisconsin Public Radio reported that Solly's Butter Burger was named an America's Classics winner by the James Beard Foundation, and that Glenn Fieber kept recipes such as the stewed onions when he renamed the restaurant Solly's Grille in 1993.

Green Bay style: Kroll's and the charcoal grill

Green Bay has another long running butter burger name at Kroll's. Harry and Caroline Kroll began serving meals at a family run hotel in 1931, then opened the first official Kroll's restaurant at 1658 Main Street in 1936. That restaurant is where the Kroll's Hamburger was first served, and Kroll's West is known today for charcoal grilled Butter Burgers.

The charcoal matters to the Green Bay version. Kroll's West describes its grilling method as a reason the burgers and sandwiches have a signature smoky flavor, a different route to Wisconsin comfort food than Solly's butter forward Milwaukee style. Kroll's West relocated in 1974 to South Ridge Road directly across from Lambeau Field, which gives a burger stop there a clear sense of place even before a plate reaches the table.

Culver's and the Sauk City chapter

Culver's gave the butter burger a Sauk City chapter in 1984. The first Culver's Frozen Custard and ButterBurger restaurant opened there on July 18, 1984. Its version is useful for travelers because it shows how a Wisconsin burger style can take a different form from one restaurant to the next.

The Culver's version turns on Ruth Culver's bun method. Craig Culver remembered his mother buttering the top of a bun and lightly grilling it until toasted, and from that habit the ButterBurger was born. Since the first restaurant opened, Culver's has offered fresh, never frozen beef, and the restaurant has become synonymous with butter burgers.

Why Wisconsin butter matters

Butter matters in this story because different Wisconsin restaurants use it to define the burger in different ways. Solly's highlights creamy Wisconsin butter alongside sirloin and Wisconsin farm fresh cheeses. Culver's builds the name around a buttered top bun that is lightly grilled until toasted. Kroll's West gives its Butter Burgers another Wisconsin route through the charcoal grill, where the restaurant says the cooking method helps create a signature smoky flavor.

Butter and simple ingredients arranged on a kitchen table in soft daylight.
AI illustration: Butter has long been a defining ingredient in the region’s cooking.

Frequently asked questions

What makes a Wisconsin butter burger different from a regular burger?

A Wisconsin butter burger is defined by the role butter plays in the burger. At Solly's, the restaurant highlights creamy Wisconsin butter, while at Culver's the ButterBurger grew from a buttered, toasted top bun.

Did the butter burger start at Solly's?

Solly's traces its original Butter Burger to 1936 Milwaukee, when Kenneth "Solly" Salmon opened Solly's Coffee Shop. Kroll's opened its first official restaurant in Green Bay in 1936, where the Kroll's Hamburger was first served. Today, Kroll's West is known for charcoal grilled Butter Burgers.

Is Culver's ButterBurger the original Wisconsin butter burger?

Culver's opened its first Frozen Custard and ButterBurger restaurant in Sauk City in 1984. Its ButterBurger comes from Ruth Culver's habit of buttering and toasting the top of the bun, while Solly's traces its original Butter Burger to 1936 Milwaukee.

Where can a visitor compare butter burger styles?

A visitor can compare versions in Milwaukee, Green Bay and Sauk City. Solly's highlights Wisconsin butter, Kroll's West shows the Green Bay charcoal grilled version, and Culver's shows the buttered bun version that made the name familiar.

Sources

Checked against each source on November 19, 2026. Opening hours, prices and event dates change, so check with the venue before you go. The illustrations are AI generated and do not show real places.

  1. Milwaukee burger restaurant named James Beard award winner (Wisconsin Public Radio)
  2. Solly's Grille, The Original Wisconsin Butter Burger (Solly's Grille)
  3. History, Kroll's West (Kroll's West)
  4. Culver's Complete Press Kit (Culver Franchising System, LLC)

More guides in Wisconsin

All Wisconsin guides Explore all five states