What Is Sugar Cream Pie In Indiana?

Published by Drafted with AI; every statement checked against its source on November 20, 2026
A sugar cream pie sits on a rustic table with simple baking ingredients in soft window light.
AI illustration: A simple pantry dessert with old fashioned ingredients.

Sugar cream pie is the Indiana pantry dessert also known as Hoosier Pie, made from simple ingredients such as sugar, milk or cream, vanilla and nutmeg instead of seasonal fruit. The dessert is often called the state pie, but the wording is careful: Visit Indiana lists sugar cream as the "Unofficial State Pie," and WFYI reported that the official push never reached the governor's desk. Its story runs through pioneer days, early Amish and Shaker communities, Winchester's Wick's Pies and today's Hoosier Pie Trail.

Key facts

  • Sugar cream pie is also known as Hoosier Pie.
  • Visit Indiana lists sugar cream as Indiana's "Unofficial State Pie."
  • The Indiana Senate passed a resolution honoring sugar cream pie on January 23, 2009.
  • The Indiana Historical Society describes it as a "desperation pie" made without seasonal ingredients like fruit.

Own a house in Indiana you are thinking of selling? See how our cash offer works.

What Sugar Cream Pie Is

Sugar cream pie is a pantry pie with sugar at its center. The filling uses cream or milk and familiar baking flavors such as cinnamon, nutmeg and vanilla, and a state recipe lists sugar, cornstarch, milk, margarine or butter, vanilla and nutmeg. It is a dessert built for a kitchen that did not need seasonal fruit on hand, which explains why it stayed useful beyond the height of fruit season.

The pie also depends on crust, not only filling. One plain rule attached to the dish says, "A good pie starts with a good crust," which keeps the dessert in the world of home baking rather than candy making.

Why Indiana Calls It Hoosier Pie

The name Hoosier Pie is more than a nickname on a recipe card. Visit Indiana says sugar cream pie is also known as Hoosier Pie. The phrase works because the dessert is tied to Indiana identity rather than to one specific town or a single restaurant.

The state symbol language needs a little care. Sugar cream pie appears on state tourism pages as "Unofficial State Pie," while other pages and trails use "Indiana's State Pie." The public ceremony behind that wording was an Indiana Senate resolution passed on January 23, 2009, honoring sugar cream pie; WFYI later reported that the official push never made it to the governor's desk.

Origins: Pioneer Days, Pantry Logic

Public accounts place the dessert in pioneer days, early Amish and Shaker communities and recipes more than a century old. The threads fit together because the pie does not require fresh fruit and can be made from staples. That is why "desperation pie" is one of its enduring names, alongside Hoosier Pie.

The Indiana Historical Society gives the cleanest warning against overclaiming the origin: the original recipe for sugar cream pie "doesn't exist." In practice, the story is about a tradition that traveled through kitchens, not a single inventor. The pie's identity centers on sugar, cream or milk and spice cabinet flavorings.

Simple pantry ingredients are arranged on a wooden kitchen table for a historic style pie recipe.
AI illustration: This pie grew out of simple pantry cooking.

How Recipes Vary

The core of sugar cream pie stays stable even as family recipes change. Sugar remains the constant ingredient, cream or milk supplies the body, and cinnamon, nutmeg and vanilla show up in the flavoring tradition. A state recipe also uses cornstarch and margarine or butter, and it measures the nutmeg as 1 teaspoon.

The lively argument is eggs. The Indiana Historical Society's brief answer to whether eggs belong is "probably shouldn't," which draws a line around the traditional filling. That does not erase family differences; it simply explains why Indiana descriptions often return to sugar, cream, crust and nutmeg instead of a long ingredient list.

Wick's Pies And Winchester

Winchester gives visitors a concrete place to connect with sugar cream pie because of Wick's Pies. The company says it has been in business since 1944, and state tourism material says the dessert was made commercially by the Wick family in the mid 1900s. That commercial chapter matters because it helped carry the pie beyond home kitchens.

Wick's Pies lists Mrs. Wick's Bakery & Cafe at 217 Greenville Avenue in Winchester, Indiana. Its site says the cafe makes 36 varieties of pie each day and includes sugar cream pie among its item details. Winchester is a commercial chapter rather than the whole origin story, but it gives the statewide tradition a specific address for a pie route.

Video: Country Crème Brûlée, Sugar Cream Pie | Across Indiana, from WFYI on YouTube. Playing it loads YouTube.

Pie Trails And Indiana Food Trips

Indiana travelers can use the Hoosier Pie Trail as a starting point for sugar cream pie trips around the state. State tourism has also promoted "Pie Day-to-Pi-Day" through the Hoosier Pie Trail and an Indiana Culinary Trails Passport. Winchester can anchor a pie outing because Wick's Pies and Mrs. Wick's Bakery & Cafe give the tradition a specific address at 217 Greenville Avenue. For a broader plate by plate trip, start with the Indiana food overview.

Slices of cream pie are served in a cozy small town bakery setting with soft daylight.
AI illustration: A pie trail stop can be as simple as a slice and a coffee.

Frequently asked questions

Is sugar cream pie the official state pie of Indiana?

The careful answer is that it is Indiana's unofficial state pie and Hoosier Pie. State tourism pages use "Unofficial State Pie," while some trails and articles still say "Indiana's State Pie." The Indiana Senate passed a resolution honoring it on January 23, 2009, but WFYI reported that the push never reached the governor's desk.

What is sugar cream pie made of?

At its base, it is sugar plus cream or milk in a pie crust. Indiana recipe descriptions include vanilla and nutmeg, and the broader flavoring tradition also includes cinnamon. One state recipe lists sugar, cornstarch, milk, margarine or butter, vanilla and nutmeg.

Why is it called desperation pie?

The name points to a dessert made without seasonal fruit. It could be put together from pantry and dairy staples. That practical origin is why the pie became known by both "desperation pie" and Hoosier Pie.

Where can visitors try sugar cream pie in Indiana?

Start with the Hoosier Pie Trail for a statewide pie route. For a historically tied stop, Wick's Pies lists Mrs. Wick's Bakery & Cafe at 217 Greenville Avenue in Winchester. State tourism has also promoted "Pie Day-to-Pi-Day" through the Hoosier Pie Trail and an Indiana Culinary Trails Passport.

Did one community invent sugar cream pie?

Indiana accounts connect sugar cream pie with early Amish and Shaker communities and pioneer days. The Indiana Historical Society says the original recipe "doesn't exist." It is safer to describe the pie as a regional tradition than as the creation of one named person or town.

Does sugar cream pie have eggs?

The traditional answer in one Indiana Historical Society note is that eggs "probably shouldn't" be included. Family recipes can vary, but public Indiana descriptions center on sugar, cream or milk, crust, vanilla and nutmeg. If a menu calls it Hoosier Pie, expect the Indiana sugar and cream tradition.

Sources

Checked against each source on November 20, 2026. Opening hours, prices and event dates change, so check with the venue before you go. The illustrations are AI generated and do not show real places.

  1. IN.gov Gallery: Sugar Cream Pie (State of Indiana / IN.gov)
  2. Official State Symbols of Indiana (Indiana Destination Development Corporation / Visit Indiana)
  3. Desperate for Pie (Indiana Historical Society)
  4. Why Is Sugar Cream Pie So Popular In Indiana? (WFYI)
  5. Sugar Cream Pie Recipe (Indiana Destination Development Corporation / Visit Indiana)
  6. Savor Sweet Treats IN Indiana (Indiana Destination Development Corporation / Visit Indiana)
  7. Wick's Pies (Wick's Pies Inc.)

More guides in Indiana

All Indiana guides Explore all five states